Introduction

As we continue to add in more vendors and find new methods of collecting data the detection chances for any single vendor can vary greatly between one day and the next. But what if you could choose two vendors? What would the detection look like?

Charts

These charts are generated daily showing the combined detection rates of all the different vendors in pairs.

Initial Detection

These charts represent what were the detection rates of when the malware was first processed.

Linux Only

AVG Authentium Avast Avira BitDefender Clam Eset FProt FSecure Ikarus McAfee Norman QuickHeal Sophos TrendMicro Vba32
AVG 85.75% 94.04% 96.96% 97.93% 94.26% 94.65% 97.58% 94.13% 92.20% 91.90% 92.69% 92.18% 90.39% 93.20% 90.09% 90.25%
Authentium 94.04% 56.06% 66.70% 69.67% 61.43% 68.79% 76.22% 60.64% 69.37% 70.63% 61.27% 60.17% 57.39% 68.69% 59.29% 59.78%
Avast 96.96% 66.70% 52.11% 63.96% 54.68% 64.84% 79.26% 55.33% 73.53% 75.07% 65.15% 66.98% 53.55% 65.06% 66.09% 64.92%
Avira 97.93% 69.67% 63.96% 52.62% 55.27% 68.59% 77.68% 54.37% 69.97% 71.50% 61.85% 67.58% 53.21% 64.71% 62.57% 61.95%
BitDefender 94.26% 61.43% 54.68% 55.27% 21.84% 60.31% 73.29% 28.53% 58.10% 60.03% 54.62% 54.19% 25.24% 53.80% 50.47% 50.32%
Clam 94.65% 68.79% 64.84% 68.59% 60.31% 54.17% 80.92% 60.05% 73.87% 74.78% 66.65% 68.28% 55.95% 66.60% 65.35% 65.40%
Eset 97.58% 76.22% 79.26% 77.68% 73.29% 80.92% 70.94% 72.18% 74.56% 75.24% 75.02% 75.76% 72.78% 81.65% 72.15% 73.14%
FProt 94.13% 60.64% 55.33% 54.37% 28.53% 60.05% 72.18% 23.35% 57.66% 60.60% 52.66% 53.49% 27.01% 52.07% 49.22% 50.07%
FSecure 92.20% 69.37% 73.53% 69.97% 58.10% 73.87% 74.56% 57.66% 47.58% 60.39% 61.18% 64.26% 53.37% 67.91% 54.96% 55.39%
Ikarus 91.90% 70.63% 75.07% 71.50% 60.03% 74.78% 75.24% 60.60% 60.39% 50.93% 62.82% 63.71% 54.72% 72.33% 53.69% 55.55%
McAfee 92.69% 61.27% 65.15% 61.85% 54.62% 66.65% 75.02% 52.66% 61.18% 62.82% 42.79% 58.01% 48.57% 63.23% 50.02% 51.44%
Norman 92.18% 60.17% 66.98% 67.58% 54.19% 68.28% 75.76% 53.49% 64.26% 63.71% 58.01% 46.78% 49.59% 64.27% 52.28% 55.32%
QuickHeal 90.39% 57.39% 53.55% 53.21% 25.24% 55.95% 72.78% 27.01% 53.37% 54.72% 48.57% 49.59% 13.25% 49.14% 42.59% 43.16%
Sophos 93.20% 68.69% 65.06% 64.71% 53.80% 66.60% 81.65% 52.07% 67.91% 72.33% 63.23% 64.27% 49.14% 47.20% 61.51% 62.20%
TrendMicro 90.09% 59.29% 66.09% 62.57% 50.47% 65.35% 72.15% 49.22% 54.96% 53.69% 50.02% 52.28% 42.59% 61.51% 37.54% 44.48%
Vba32 90.25% 59.78% 64.92% 61.95% 50.32% 65.40% 73.14% 50.07% 55.39% 55.55% 51.44% 55.32% 43.16% 62.20% 44.48% 37.39%

Windows Only

AVG AhnLab Authentium Avast Avira BitDefender Clam Comodo Eset FProt FSecure Fortinet GData Ikarus K7 Kaspersky Lionic McAfee Microsoft Norman PCTools QuickHeal Sophos Sunbelt Symantec TrendMicro
AVG 82.86% 88.32% 90.71% 95.83% 94.54% 89.23% 92.93% 96.81% 91.23% 90.99% 89.81% 87.26% 91.92% 92.16% 95.82% 83.62% 89.70% 93.27% 85.12% 83.83% 87.35% 89.24% 88.92% 83.80% 93.32% 88.27%
AhnLab 88.32% 43.24% 57.51% 85.99% 64.44% 59.43% 66.44% 94.05% 66.91% 83.60% 73.03% 50.56% 63.81% 90.65% 90.54% 47.47% 49.37% 76.82% 57.33% 50.11% 47.31% 78.25% 71.83% 57.05% 92.36% 47.30%
Authentium 90.71% 57.51% 50.91% 87.11% 66.52% 62.22% 69.56% 94.53% 64.91% 83.59% 78.57% 58.07% 65.72% 92.48% 91.96% 53.45% 56.73% 80.48% 58.25% 52.09% 52.73% 78.91% 78.98% 59.61% 94.30% 52.29%
Avast 95.83% 85.99% 87.11% 79.68% 85.95% 85.04% 88.06% 98.83% 88.27% 90.42% 86.96% 83.17% 87.10% 96.85% 94.93% 80.86% 84.58% 87.69% 87.37% 83.42% 82.12% 90.04% 88.27% 85.51% 97.89% 83.34%
Avira 94.54% 64.44% 66.52% 85.95% 50.81% 57.01% 70.50% 98.88% 65.80% 90.77% 83.41% 56.42% 58.42% 96.20% 91.89% 52.42% 55.78% 83.41% 67.88% 62.13% 57.48% 90.98% 84.39% 69.16% 97.70% 60.57%
BitDefender 89.23% 59.43% 62.22% 85.04% 57.01% 47.27% 70.40% 98.00% 61.98% 87.12% 80.35% 53.87% 57.40% 92.94% 91.65% 48.93% 55.83% 83.04% 59.90% 54.76% 51.91% 86.54% 80.61% 61.33% 94.93% 55.62%
Clam 92.93% 66.44% 69.56% 88.06% 70.50% 70.40% 49.99% 95.42% 74.89% 89.96% 78.99% 61.08% 69.64% 94.08% 93.80% 53.81% 57.55% 76.71% 68.73% 62.99% 63.37% 85.74% 78.97% 67.08% 95.09% 65.32%
Comodo 96.81% 94.05% 94.53% 98.83% 98.88% 98.00% 95.42% 92.64% 98.87% 97.04% 95.61% 94.79% 98.68% 97.44% 98.49% 93.32% 94.60% 96.00% 94.28% 93.16% 94.32% 94.29% 95.45% 93.83% 98.56% 94.01%
Eset 91.23% 66.91% 64.91% 88.27% 65.80% 61.98% 74.89% 98.87% 55.51% 89.23% 84.71% 61.39% 66.12% 94.64% 92.96% 56.64% 64.43% 84.08% 59.50% 56.27% 61.03% 88.37% 85.25% 62.27% 95.73% 63.33%
FProt 90.99% 83.60% 83.59% 90.42% 90.77% 87.12% 89.96% 97.04% 89.23% 78.82% 84.48% 81.96% 88.13% 93.92% 94.46% 79.97% 86.64% 88.66% 84.19% 79.89% 79.89% 82.16% 84.94% 80.23% 95.57% 82.04%
FSecure 89.81% 73.03% 78.57% 86.96% 83.41% 80.35% 78.99% 95.61% 84.71% 84.48% 67.06% 73.86% 83.11% 91.85% 93.25% 69.46% 73.77% 78.04% 76.45% 71.33% 71.68% 81.87% 73.74% 73.69% 93.75% 73.02%
Fortinet 87.26% 50.56% 58.07% 83.17% 56.42% 53.87% 61.08% 94.79% 61.39% 81.96% 73.86% 23.96% 54.18% 92.24% 90.39% 31.15% 46.05% 71.12% 53.53% 41.92% 43.81% 77.68% 73.75% 48.07% 92.52% 49.04%
GData 91.92% 63.81% 65.72% 87.10% 58.42% 57.40% 69.64% 98.68% 66.12% 88.13% 83.11% 54.18% 45.54% 95.52% 91.71% 46.96% 54.18% 80.97% 65.05% 57.75% 56.20% 87.60% 83.14% 63.64% 96.31% 60.38%
Ikarus 92.16% 90.65% 92.48% 96.85% 96.20% 92.94% 94.08% 97.44% 94.64% 93.92% 91.85% 92.24% 95.52% 88.97% 96.86% 89.59% 92.15% 94.73% 89.21% 89.23% 90.86% 91.62% 91.39% 89.88% 94.88% 90.61%
K7 95.82% 90.54% 91.96% 94.93% 91.89% 91.65% 93.80% 98.49% 92.96% 94.46% 93.25% 90.39% 91.71% 96.86% 89.24% 89.59% 90.57% 93.80% 92.07% 91.03% 90.33% 94.37% 92.75% 91.72% 97.90% 90.52%
Kaspersky 83.62% 47.47% 53.45% 80.86% 52.42% 48.93% 53.81% 93.32% 56.64% 79.97% 69.46% 31.15% 46.96% 89.59% 89.59% 10.12% 36.10% 67.32% 46.96% 30.67% 38.53% 73.67% 69.62% 37.66% 90.60% 44.02%
Lionic 89.70% 49.37% 56.73% 84.58% 55.78% 55.83% 57.55% 94.60% 64.43% 86.64% 73.77% 46.05% 54.18% 92.15% 90.57% 36.10% 30.84% 74.97% 55.87% 49.83% 45.97% 81.79% 73.56% 56.99% 93.29% 48.12%
McAfee 93.27% 76.82% 80.48% 87.69% 83.41% 83.04% 76.71% 96.00% 84.08% 88.66% 78.04% 71.12% 80.97% 94.73% 93.80% 67.32% 74.97% 61.83% 78.73% 70.74% 74.51% 84.51% 79.81% 72.65% 95.68% 76.50%
Microsoft 85.12% 57.33% 58.25% 87.37% 67.88% 59.90% 68.73% 94.28% 59.50% 84.19% 76.45% 53.53% 65.05% 89.21% 92.07% 46.96% 55.87% 78.73% 43.72% 46.63% 52.06% 78.80% 76.57% 49.82% 90.51% 53.92%
Norman 83.83% 50.11% 52.09% 83.42% 62.13% 54.76% 62.99% 93.16% 56.27% 79.89% 71.33% 41.92% 57.75% 89.23% 91.03% 30.67% 49.83% 70.74% 46.63% 27.87% 42.92% 73.33% 72.02% 38.90% 91.07% 46.63%
PCTools 87.35% 47.31% 52.73% 82.12% 57.48% 51.91% 63.37% 94.32% 61.03% 79.89% 71.68% 43.81% 56.20% 90.86% 90.33% 38.53% 45.97% 74.51% 52.06% 42.92% 34.93% 74.44% 71.42% 50.70% 92.66% 43.41%
QuickHeal 89.24% 78.25% 78.91% 90.04% 90.98% 86.54% 85.74% 94.29% 88.37% 82.16% 81.87% 77.68% 87.60% 91.62% 94.37% 73.67% 81.79% 84.51% 78.80% 73.33% 74.44% 71.92% 82.56% 74.18% 93.68% 76.41%
Sophos 88.92% 71.83% 78.98% 88.27% 84.39% 80.61% 78.97% 95.45% 85.25% 84.94% 73.74% 73.75% 83.14% 91.39% 92.75% 69.62% 73.56% 79.81% 76.57% 72.02% 71.42% 82.56% 66.83% 74.09% 93.11% 72.66%
Sunbelt 83.80% 57.05% 59.61% 85.51% 69.16% 61.33% 67.08% 93.83% 62.27% 80.23% 73.69% 48.07% 63.64% 89.88% 91.72% 37.66% 56.99% 72.65% 49.82% 38.90% 50.70% 74.18% 74.09% 33.76% 90.49% 54.72%
Symantec 93.32% 92.36% 94.30% 97.89% 97.70% 94.93% 95.09% 98.56% 95.73% 95.57% 93.75% 92.52% 96.31% 94.88% 97.90% 90.60% 93.29% 95.68% 90.51% 91.07% 92.66% 93.68% 93.11% 90.49% 89.77% 92.56%
TrendMicro 88.27% 47.30% 52.29% 83.34% 60.57% 55.62% 65.32% 94.01% 63.33% 82.04% 73.02% 49.04% 60.38% 90.61% 90.52% 44.02% 48.12% 76.50% 53.92% 46.63% 43.41% 76.41% 72.66% 54.72% 92.56% 40.57%

After Retries

These charts represent after a full day of multiple tests by each vendor on all the malware collected.

Linux Only

AVG Authentium Avast Avira BitDefender Clam Eset FProt FSecure Ikarus McAfee Norman QuickHeal Sophos TrendMicro Vba32
AVG 90.02% 95.23% 97.60% 98.46% 94.77% 95.75% 97.20% 94.95% 93.80% 92.75% 94.60% 93.71% 92.37% 94.64% 92.19% 92.83%
Authentium 95.23% 31.19% 42.77% 47.76% 37.03% 53.21% 54.54% 39.74% 50.56% 41.31% 37.05% 35.53% 33.59% 46.62% 33.21% 39.21%
Avast 97.60% 42.77% 38.55% 48.86% 41.20% 56.34% 58.76% 45.00% 58.31% 48.29% 42.73% 41.59% 40.72% 53.00% 40.50% 44.98%
Avira 98.46% 47.76% 48.86% 39.69% 41.92% 59.18% 56.95% 43.23% 57.67% 46.94% 42.88% 43.68% 40.13% 51.78% 40.07% 45.01%
BitDefender 94.77% 37.03% 41.20% 41.92% 21.47% 53.22% 50.45% 28.53% 45.26% 33.00% 34.73% 28.09% 25.24% 44.21% 26.99% 34.28%
Clam 95.75% 53.21% 56.34% 59.18% 53.22% 47.03% 65.60% 54.37% 63.58% 55.56% 52.86% 51.29% 48.90% 59.32% 48.93% 52.07%
Eset 97.20% 54.54% 58.76% 56.95% 50.45% 65.60% 47.05% 49.43% 54.26% 49.14% 52.52% 53.28% 49.51% 62.77% 48.89% 52.60%
FProt 94.95% 39.74% 45.00% 43.23% 28.53% 54.37% 49.43% 23.36% 44.81% 33.71% 35.33% 30.57% 27.02% 44.65% 28.02% 35.79%
FSecure 93.80% 50.56% 58.31% 57.67% 45.26% 63.58% 54.26% 44.81% 34.97% 43.50% 47.34% 45.42% 40.68% 57.70% 39.76% 45.29%
Ikarus 92.75% 41.31% 48.29% 46.94% 33.00% 55.56% 49.14% 33.71% 43.50% 24.45% 37.39% 34.47% 27.79% 49.46% 27.69% 34.77%
McAfee 94.60% 37.05% 42.73% 42.88% 34.73% 52.86% 52.52% 35.33% 47.34% 37.39% 23.41% 32.88% 29.17% 43.97% 27.28% 34.74%
Norman 93.71% 35.53% 41.59% 43.68% 28.09% 51.29% 53.28% 30.57% 45.42% 34.47% 32.88% 20.12% 23.74% 40.56% 24.92% 34.46%
QuickHeal 92.37% 33.59% 40.72% 40.13% 25.24% 48.90% 49.51% 27.02% 40.68% 27.79% 29.17% 23.74% 14.91% 39.72% 19.26% 27.88%
Sophos 94.64% 46.62% 53.00% 51.78% 44.21% 59.32% 62.77% 44.65% 57.70% 49.46% 43.97% 40.56% 39.72% 37.59% 38.56% 45.51%
TrendMicro 92.19% 33.21% 40.50% 40.07% 26.99% 48.93% 48.89% 28.02% 39.76% 27.69% 27.28% 24.92% 19.26% 38.56% 14.12% 26.64%
Vba32 92.83% 39.21% 44.98% 45.01% 34.28% 52.07% 52.60% 35.79% 45.29% 34.77% 34.74% 34.46% 27.88% 45.51% 26.64% 22.72%

Windows Only

AVG AhnLab Authentium Avast Avira BitDefender Clam Comodo Eset FProt FSecure Fortinet GData Ikarus K7 Kaspersky Lionic McAfee Microsoft Norman PCTools QuickHeal Sophos Sunbelt Symantec TrendMicro
AVG 82.87% 88.33% 90.75% 95.84% 94.74% 89.43% 92.94% 96.82% 90.01% 91.05% 89.86% 92.19% 92.20% 92.19% 95.87% 84.36% 89.75% 94.56% 83.93% 84.16% 87.52% 89.38% 88.93% 83.94% 93.33% 88.31%
AhnLab 88.33% 31.45% 41.02% 85.53% 52.18% 46.65% 59.13% 94.05% 47.03% 83.80% 71.07% 48.00% 52.83% 90.69% 90.64% 37.51% 37.69% 77.09% 34.64% 34.17% 35.74% 78.48% 69.93% 34.88% 92.37% 35.46%
Authentium 90.75% 41.02% 34.48% 84.07% 49.43% 44.80% 59.15% 94.53% 45.23% 83.85% 75.41% 48.46% 50.80% 92.52% 91.44% 38.74% 40.34% 78.37% 35.81% 35.93% 36.55% 79.44% 75.52% 36.71% 94.30% 35.99%
Avast 95.84% 85.53% 84.07% 79.69% 84.54% 82.65% 88.07% 98.83% 81.64% 90.43% 86.97% 85.06% 86.54% 96.87% 95.10% 81.29% 84.61% 88.12% 80.11% 80.67% 81.85% 90.17% 88.28% 80.67% 97.89% 82.77%
Avira 94.74% 52.18% 49.43% 84.54% 44.83% 45.73% 66.93% 98.88% 45.66% 90.20% 81.74% 50.92% 53.17% 96.34% 92.22% 46.89% 50.12% 82.07% 44.95% 45.27% 46.73% 90.51% 82.98% 45.37% 97.76% 48.08%
BitDefender 89.43% 46.65% 44.80% 82.65% 45.73% 35.86% 63.71% 98.01% 40.89% 86.01% 77.18% 46.50% 47.36% 93.16% 91.54% 38.59% 45.25% 80.41% 35.98% 37.10% 40.54% 85.43% 78.19% 36.93% 95.09% 42.67%
Clam 92.94% 59.13% 59.15% 88.07% 66.93% 63.71% 50.00% 95.43% 62.63% 90.08% 79.06% 64.66% 67.83% 94.12% 93.94% 54.79% 57.61% 79.79% 54.71% 53.20% 57.28% 85.91% 78.97% 52.70% 95.09% 57.87%
Comodo 96.82% 94.05% 94.53% 98.83% 98.88% 98.01% 95.43% 92.64% 98.87% 97.12% 95.65% 98.16% 98.69% 97.47% 98.63% 93.63% 94.62% 97.58% 94.29% 93.25% 94.33% 94.30% 95.45% 93.88% 98.57% 94.02%
Eset 90.01% 47.03% 45.23% 81.64% 45.66% 40.89% 62.63% 98.87% 32.54% 85.73% 78.24% 44.72% 47.68% 94.53% 91.55% 35.41% 45.30% 77.36% 33.39% 33.81% 39.71% 84.27% 79.28% 33.62% 95.87% 43.06%
FProt 91.05% 83.80% 83.85% 90.43% 90.20% 86.01% 90.08% 97.12% 85.73% 79.16% 84.60% 86.81% 88.19% 93.97% 94.51% 81.05% 86.79% 90.26% 80.29% 80.44% 80.51% 82.38% 85.03% 80.57% 95.61% 82.37%
FSecure 89.86% 71.07% 75.41% 86.97% 81.74% 77.18% 79.06% 95.65% 78.24% 84.60% 67.17% 79.85% 82.51% 91.90% 93.40% 70.52% 73.88% 80.39% 69.17% 68.58% 70.17% 82.10% 73.80% 69.47% 93.76% 70.88%
Fortinet 92.19% 48.00% 48.46% 85.06% 50.92% 46.50% 64.66% 98.16% 44.72% 86.81% 79.85% 39.03% 51.69% 96.16% 91.59% 43.41% 47.36% 80.61% 40.58% 41.73% 43.70% 86.50% 80.26% 40.34% 97.21% 46.33%
GData 92.20% 52.83% 50.80% 86.54% 53.17% 47.36% 67.83% 98.69% 47.68% 88.19% 82.51% 51.69% 42.65% 95.64% 92.28% 44.49% 51.01% 81.07% 44.11% 43.34% 46.99% 87.89% 82.49% 43.01% 96.43% 49.39%
Ikarus 92.19% 90.69% 92.52% 96.87% 96.34% 93.16% 94.12% 97.47% 94.53% 93.97% 91.90% 96.16% 95.64% 89.02% 97.00% 90.02% 92.22% 95.97% 89.27% 89.41% 90.91% 91.79% 91.42% 89.98% 94.89% 90.65%
K7 95.87% 90.64% 91.44% 95.10% 92.22% 91.54% 93.94% 98.63% 91.55% 94.51% 93.40% 91.59% 92.28% 97.00% 90.34% 90.67% 91.63% 94.23% 90.62% 90.64% 90.66% 94.64% 92.90% 90.60% 97.92% 90.62%
Kaspersky 84.36% 37.51% 38.74% 81.29% 46.89% 38.59% 54.79% 93.63% 35.41% 81.05% 70.52% 43.41% 44.49% 90.02% 90.67% 12.78% 37.17% 72.34% 23.56% 17.58% 30.71% 75.05% 70.55% 18.04% 91.05% 34.05%
Lionic 89.75% 37.69% 40.34% 84.61% 50.12% 45.25% 57.61% 94.62% 45.30% 86.79% 73.88% 47.36% 51.01% 92.22% 91.63% 37.17% 31.04% 77.63% 33.98% 33.95% 36.06% 82.01% 73.61% 34.23% 93.33% 36.34%
McAfee 94.56% 77.09% 78.37% 88.12% 82.07% 80.41% 79.79% 97.58% 77.36% 90.26% 80.39% 80.61% 81.07% 95.97% 94.23% 72.34% 77.63% 69.03% 73.07% 71.23% 75.19% 87.11% 82.58% 71.11% 96.80% 76.49%
Microsoft 83.93% 34.64% 35.81% 80.11% 44.95% 35.98% 54.71% 94.29% 33.39% 80.29% 69.17% 40.58% 44.11% 89.27% 90.62% 23.56% 33.98% 73.07% 17.33% 21.22% 27.69% 74.13% 70.04% 20.57% 90.64% 30.86%
Norman 84.16% 34.17% 35.93% 80.67% 45.27% 37.10% 53.20% 93.25% 33.81% 80.44% 68.58% 41.73% 43.34% 89.41% 90.64% 17.58% 33.95% 71.23% 21.22% 12.48% 27.47% 73.91% 68.91% 16.91% 91.23% 30.71%
PCTools 87.52% 35.74% 36.55% 81.85% 46.73% 40.54% 57.28% 94.33% 39.71% 80.51% 70.17% 43.70% 46.99% 90.91% 90.66% 30.71% 36.06% 75.19% 27.69% 27.47% 25.36% 75.14% 69.94% 28.39% 92.67% 31.85%
QuickHeal 89.38% 78.48% 79.44% 90.17% 90.51% 85.43% 85.91% 94.30% 84.27% 82.38% 82.10% 86.50% 87.89% 91.79% 94.64% 75.05% 82.01% 87.11% 74.13% 73.91% 75.14% 72.14% 82.74% 74.57% 93.72% 76.89%
Sophos 88.93% 69.93% 75.52% 88.28% 82.98% 78.19% 78.97% 95.45% 79.28% 85.03% 73.80% 80.26% 82.49% 91.42% 92.90% 70.55% 73.61% 82.58% 70.04% 68.91% 69.94% 82.74% 66.83% 69.50% 93.11% 70.66%
Sunbelt 83.94% 34.88% 36.71% 80.67% 45.37% 36.93% 52.70% 93.88% 33.62% 80.57% 69.47% 40.34% 43.01% 89.98% 90.60% 18.04% 34.23% 71.11% 20.57% 16.91% 28.39% 74.57% 69.50% 10.86% 90.59% 31.90%
Symantec 93.33% 92.37% 94.30% 97.89% 97.76% 95.09% 95.09% 98.57% 95.87% 95.61% 93.76% 97.21% 96.43% 94.89% 97.92% 91.05% 93.33% 96.80% 90.64% 91.23% 92.67% 93.72% 93.11% 90.59% 89.78% 92.57%
TrendMicro 88.31% 35.46% 35.99% 82.77% 48.08% 42.67% 57.87% 94.02% 43.06% 82.37% 70.88% 46.33% 49.39% 90.65% 90.62% 34.05% 36.34% 76.49% 30.86% 30.71% 31.85% 76.89% 70.66% 31.90% 92.57% 28.73%