Introduction

After developing the statistics for combined detection rates we felt the need to summarize that data into smaller charts. These charts are showing the combined performance of the different vendors in pairs. Instead of using a matrix table these are being represented in a single listing.

Charts

These charts are generated once a day from the existing Combined Results charts. We are only showing the first 20 of each table otherwise each chart would be hundreds of lines long.

Initial Combined Results for all Vendors

Pair Alone Combined
Ikarus + Symantec 89.28%/81.74% 96.10%
Ikarus + Sunbelt 89.28%/84.50% 95.27%
Comodo + Sunbelt 87.97%/84.50% 95.03%
Comodo + Symantec 87.97%/81.74% 94.77%
Comodo + Ikarus 87.97%/89.28% 94.47%
Emsisoft + Ikarus 58.59%/89.28% 94.14%
Sunbelt + Symantec 84.50%/81.74% 93.99%
K7 + Symantec 80.50%/81.74% 93.68%
Ikarus + K7 89.28%/80.50% 93.51%
Comodo + GData 87.97%/73.44% 93.46%
Comodo + K7 87.97%/80.50% 93.46%
Comodo + Emsisoft 87.97%/58.59% 93.40%
K7 + Sunbelt 80.50%/84.50% 93.29%
Clam + Comodo 60.39%/87.97% 92.82%
Avira + Ikarus 61.39%/89.28% 92.75%
Ikarus + McAfee 89.28%/63.37% 92.69%
BitDefender + Ikarus 77.33%/89.28% 92.55%
GData + Ikarus 73.44%/89.28% 92.54%
Clam + Ikarus 60.39%/89.28% 92.42%
Fortinet + Sunbelt 61.16%/84.50% 92.33%

Initial Combined Results for only Linux Scanners

Pair Alone Combined
AVG + Ikarus 59.62%/89.57% 95.41%
Ikarus + McAfee 89.57%/71.35% 93.59%
DrWeb + Ikarus 64.83%/89.57% 93.20%
Avira + Ikarus 62.66%/89.57% 92.95%
Clam + Ikarus 67.81%/89.57% 92.93%
BitDefender + Ikarus 77.48%/89.57% 92.64%
Avast + Ikarus 58.83%/89.57% 92.01%
Ikarus + VirusBlokAda 89.57%/62.49% 91.80%
Eset + Ikarus 65.01%/89.57% 91.77%
Ikarus + VirusBuster 89.57%/72.63% 91.66%
Ikarus + Vba32 89.57%/66.80% 91.40%
Authentium + Ikarus 58.87%/89.57% 91.23%
FProt + Ikarus 54.51%/89.57% 91.02%
Ikarus + QuickHeal 89.57%/54.33% 90.98%
Ikarus + Vexira 89.57%/58.78% 90.70%
AVG + BitDefender 59.62%/77.48% 90.69%
Ikarus + Sophos 89.57%/46.63% 90.59%
Ikarus + Norman 89.57%/25.29% 90.03%
Ikarus + Panda 89.57%/36.13% 89.79%
FSecure + Ikarus 36.26%/89.57% 89.73%

Initial Combined Results for only Windows Scanners

Pair Alone Combined
Sunbelt + TrendMicro 84.50%/75.53% 96.60%
Avira + Symantec 79.41%/81.74% 96.36%
Ikarus + Symantec 90.37%/81.74% 96.22%
Ikarus + TrendMicro 90.37%/75.53% 95.49%
Ikarus + Sunbelt 90.37%/84.50% 95.30%
Comodo + Sunbelt 87.97%/84.50% 95.03%
Avira + FSecure 79.41%/76.60% 94.82%
Comodo + Ikarus 87.97%/90.37% 94.80%
Comodo + Symantec 87.97%/81.74% 94.77%
Avast + Sunbelt 87.30%/84.50% 94.72%
Avast + Ikarus 87.30%/90.37% 94.72%
Avast + K7 87.30%/80.50% 94.71%
FSecure + Sunbelt 76.60%/84.50% 94.64%
GData + TrendMicro 73.44%/75.53% 94.51%
Emsisoft + Ikarus 58.59%/90.37% 94.45%
Avast + Avira 87.30%/79.41% 94.38%
Avira + Ikarus 79.41%/90.37% 94.28%
FSecure + Ikarus 76.60%/90.37% 94.26%
Comodo + TrendMicro 87.97%/75.53% 94.24%
Avira + Comodo 79.41%/87.97% 94.19%

Retested Combined Results for all Vendors

Pair Alone Combined
Sunbelt + Symantec 92.62%/87.62% 98.33%
Emsisoft + Sunbelt 79.02%/92.62% 97.18%
Ikarus + Symantec 91.52%/87.62% 97.14%
Comodo + Symantec 90.91%/87.62% 96.95%
Comodo + Emsisoft 90.91%/79.02% 96.94%
Emsisoft + Ikarus 79.02%/91.52% 96.67%
Ikarus + Sunbelt 91.52%/92.62% 96.08%
Emsisoft + Symantec 79.02%/87.62% 95.77%
Comodo + Sunbelt 90.91%/92.62% 95.74%
Comodo + Ikarus 90.91%/91.52% 95.14%
Avast + Sunbelt 75.97%/92.62% 95.06%
K7 + Symantec 80.83%/87.62% 94.78%
Clam + Symantec 75.74%/87.62% 94.72%
Emsisoft + K7 79.02%/80.83% 94.69%
AVG + Sunbelt 82.65%/92.62% 94.63%
K7 + Sunbelt 80.83%/92.62% 94.60%
Avira + Sunbelt 74.96%/92.62% 94.57%
Clam + Sunbelt 75.74%/92.62% 94.54%
Fortinet + Sunbelt 80.92%/92.62% 94.50%
BitDefender + Sunbelt 82.98%/92.62% 94.49%

Retested Combined Results for only Linux Scanners

Pair Alone Combined
AVG + Ikarus 97.95%/91.53% 99.66%
AVG + VirusBuster 97.95%/82.60% 99.44%
AVG + Avira 97.95%/75.42% 99.29%
AVG + BitDefender 97.95%/82.98% 99.25%
AVG + Clam 97.95%/81.21% 99.22%
AVG + McAfee 97.95%/80.24% 99.16%
AVG + DrWeb 97.95%/77.53% 99.12%
AVG + Avast 97.95%/75.97% 99.07%
AVG + Vba32 97.95%/72.65% 98.95%
AVG + Eset 97.95%/71.90% 98.94%
AVG + VirusBlokAda 97.95%/72.95% 98.94%
AVG + Authentium 97.95%/69.81% 98.92%
AVG + QuickHeal 97.95%/64.89% 98.79%
AVG + Vexira 97.95%/61.04% 98.70%
AVG + FProt 97.95%/63.49% 98.62%
AVG + Sophos 97.95%/58.67% 98.59%
AVG + Norman 97.95%/46.68% 98.46%
AVG + FSecure 97.95%/45.55% 98.27%
AVG + TrendMicro 97.95%/31.46% 98.26%
AVG + Panda 97.95%/36.13% 98.03%

Retested Combined Results for only Windows Scanners

Pair Alone Combined
Sunbelt + Symantec 92.62%/87.62% 98.33%
Avira + Symantec 87.14%/87.62% 98.14%
Emsisoft + TrendMicro 79.02%/75.53% 97.90%
Emsisoft + Sunbelt 79.02%/92.62% 97.18%
Ikarus + Symantec 91.63%/87.62% 97.16%
Avira + Emsisoft 87.14%/79.02% 97.01%
Comodo + Symantec 90.91%/87.62% 96.95%
Comodo + Emsisoft 90.91%/79.02% 96.94%
Sunbelt + TrendMicro 92.62%/75.53% 96.81%
Emsisoft + Ikarus 79.02%/91.63% 96.71%
Ikarus + TrendMicro 91.63%/75.53% 96.36%
Avast + Emsisoft 88.11%/79.02% 96.13%
Ikarus + Sunbelt 91.63%/92.62% 96.11%
FSecure + Sunbelt 77.48%/92.62% 96.05%
Avast + Sunbelt 88.11%/92.62% 95.78%
Emsisoft + Symantec 79.02%/87.62% 95.77%
Comodo + Sunbelt 90.91%/92.62% 95.74%
Comodo + TrendMicro 90.91%/75.53% 95.56%
Avast + K7 88.11%/80.83% 95.41%
Emsisoft + FSecure 79.02%/77.48% 95.40%